Fiba Europe Cup Basketball

Having spent over a decade analyzing football dynamics across Asia, I've always found the "best player" debate particularly fascinating in the Indian context. While many fans immediately jump to Sunil Chhetri's name—and understandably so—I believe the conversation deserves more nuance than simply pointing to the national team captain. The truth is, evaluating football greatness involves examining multiple dimensions: technical skill, leadership impact, consistency, and that intangible quality of elevating everyone around them. This reminds me of something I observed in volleyball recently—Bernadeth Pons, the newly-minted Reinforced Conference MVP, made an interesting point about Creamline's offseason camps in Japan and Taiwan giving them a much-needed reality check. That concept applies perfectly to Indian football too. Sometimes, you need that external perspective to truly understand where you stand, regardless of your domestic achievements.

When I first started watching Indian football regularly around 2012, the landscape was dramatically different. The I-League was the primary competition, and the talent pool seemed more concentrated. Today, with the Indian Super League's influence and increased foreign exposure, we're seeing a more diverse range of skills and playing styles. My personal methodology for ranking players involves watching at least 15-20 full matches per season, analyzing performance data, and speaking with coaches who understand the game's technical aspects. I've always preferred players who demonstrate consistency over flashy one-off performances—the ones who show up match after match, making their teams better even when they're not scoring headlines.

Let's address the elephant in the room: Sunil Chhetri. With 84 international goals in 132 appearances, his numbers speak volumes. I've had the privilege of watching him play live on seven occasions, and what consistently stands out isn't just his finishing—which is exceptional—but his movement off the ball. At 38 years old, he still outworks defenders mentally, finding spaces that shouldn't exist. However, here's where I might diverge from popular opinion: in terms of pure technical ability and potential impact on the game's future, I believe we need to look beyond Chhetri. His leadership is unquestioned, but football evolves, and new talents are emerging who might not have his goal tally but bring different qualities to the pitch.

The conversation inevitably turns to younger talents like Sahal Abdul Samad, who represents the technical evolution of Indian football. Having watched Sahal develop from his Kerala Blasters days to his current role at Mohun Bagan, I've noticed something fascinating—his dribbling success rate in crowded midfield areas sits around 68%, which for an Indian midfielder is remarkably high. What Sahal lacks in Chhetri's goal-scoring instinct, he makes up for in creative fluidity. Then there's Gurpreet Singh Sandhu, who in my opinion remains criminally underrated in these discussions. Goalkeepers rarely get their due, but Gurpreet's performances for Bengaluru FC and the national team have been consistently outstanding. I recall specifically a match against Barcelona in a friendly where he made eight saves against world-class opposition—the kind of performance that should cement his place in any serious conversation about India's best.

What many fans overlook is how the definition of "best" changes with context. For club performance, I'd argue players like Liston Colaco deserve more recognition. His pace and crossing accuracy have transformed ATK Mohun Bagan's attacking options, creating 34 scoring chances last season alone. For national team impact, Chhetri's leadership during the 2019 Asian Cup qualifiers was arguably more valuable than any statistical contribution. And for pure technical development, young talents like Anirudh Thapa represent the future—his passing range and vision suggest he could become the complete midfielder India has lacked for generations.

The Bernadeth Pons observation about international exposure providing reality checks resonates deeply with me regarding Indian football. Having accompanied the national team during their preparation camps in 2018, I witnessed firsthand how matches against Middle Eastern and Central Asian opponents revealed technical and tactical gaps that domestic success had masked. This is why I place significant weight on performances against quality international opposition when evaluating players. Chhetri's hat-trick against Tajikistan in 2019 stands out, but so does Sandesh Jhingan's dominant defensive display against Oman the same year.

My personal ranking might surprise some readers, but after careful consideration, I'd position Sunil Chhetri at the top, followed closely by Gurpreet Singh Sandhu, with Sandesh Jhingan completing my top three. Where I differ from many analysts is in having Gurpreet so high—but when I consider match-winning impact relative to position, his consistency at the highest level justifies this placement. Sahal Abdul Samad and Anirudh Thapa round out my top five, representing the technical future of Indian football.

The beautiful complexity of this debate is that there's no single right answer. What makes a player "the best" depends on what qualities you value most—be it leadership, technical skill, consistency, or the ability to perform when it matters most. Having watched Indian football evolve through multiple generations, what excites me most isn't the current hierarchy but the emerging talent that promises to make this conversation even more interesting in the coming years. The reality check Pons described applies perfectly—as Indian football continues to develop through international exposure, our understanding of greatness will undoubtedly evolve alongside it.